My Birthday Gift From PeerStreet

Photo by Andreas Weiland on Unsplash

Back in September I opened my PeerStreet account, funded it, and made my first investment. In this post I will provide an update on how the investments are performing and share what I’ve learned about PeerStreet’s automated investing tool, plus the birthday gift they recently sent me.

Automated Investing

I originally set the automated investing tool to 7%+ interest rate, “Up to 65%” LTV, and “Up to 24 months” loan term. My hope was that the tool would grab the highest interest rate opportunities with better loan-to-value ratios, but this didn’t happen. The tool grabs the lower interest rate properties first. This wasn’t a problem because investors have 24 hours to cancel the automated transaction. If you are wanting to invest in the higher interest rate offerings then my recommendation is that you set the interest rate at the level you want and change the LTV to “Up to 75%” and terms to “Up to 60 months”. It is unlikely that you will get a higher interest loan that goes beyond 24 months. The automated investment tool will increase the chances you catch one of the higher rates, because they fill up fast when they are posted. Loans in the 7% range are offered regularly and easy to grab without the automated tool.

Portfolio Performance

I funded my PeerStreet account with $10,000 and started investing $2000 per loan in late September. After figuring out what kind of loans the automated investing tool would grab and cancelling out of three loans, I spread the money across a range of interest rates and loan terms. The total interest for the portfolio is 7.85%. All loans are currently performing.

The loans are paying at different times and I received a partial month payment for the four loans that had one or more business weeks in September (Carmel-by-the-Sea, Los Angeles, and both San Diego properties). So far I’m pleased with PeerStreet because my cash is making way more money than it would locked up in a CD or other fixed income instrument.

There are downsides that investors to think about before using PeerStreet. These loans are locking up my money even more than a CD does because I can’t sell these loans. I have to wait until the borrower pays off the loan before I get my money back. I also don’t have the same guarantees as a CD would give me. The borrower can pay the loan off early or they could never pay it back. The ability to pay back the loan early is part of the value proposition to the borrower and helps create the opportunity for me to invest with PeerStreet, so this doesn’t bother me. It is possible that the borrower could default on the loan, however PeerStreet is sitting in first position to get repaid and the loan is backed by real estate with some equity available. So in a default situation my money would remain tied up, but PeerStreet will deal with the headache of getting repaid. As long as I’m not investing money I’m going to need to access in the short-term (fewer than 5 years) then I feel good about this kind of investment.

Birthday Present from PeerStreet

It was my 45th birthday recently and the nice people at PeerStreet sent me a gift. They gave me a 1% yield bump on my next investment! Very cool. Thank you!!!

3 Replies to “My Birthday Gift From PeerStreet”

    1. Damn Millennial – You are officially the first person to ever post a comment here on Rich Incog Blog! Thank you!!!

      The PeerStreet investment represents less than 1% of our total portfolio (about .6 as of this morning). I’m working on a post about how we plan to use the profits, and hope that other people will imitate. I hope to publish that later this month. I don’t think I will put a whole lot more money to work in PeerStreet. If we decide we want to have more exposure to real estate then we would invest in a Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) with a company like PassCo or Shoppoff. A DST would provide us with monthly interest payments similar to PeerStreet and we would potentially see a capital gain in 5-7 years when the property is sold again. The capital gains in a DST qualify for 1031 Exchange, which means would enjoy some of the benefits of direct real estate investing without having to be landlords. BTW, PeerStreet and DST investments both are limited to accredited investors as defined by the SEC.
      – Rich

  1. I’m wondering if you got a second birthday gift in December? My birthday is coming up in a few days and I’m wondering if I should wait for the extra 1% before I invest.

Please let us know what you think

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.